• Tackling insurance fraud in Nepal

    Tackling insurance fraud in Nepal

    By Danny Kaine —

    Systematic fraud in Nepal is estimated to have cost insurers millions of dollars and has allegedly caused the deaths of a number of travellers. Traveller Assist, a medical assistance and cost containment company, believes it has uncovered a network of fraudulent activity that involves a number of trekking operators, helicopter companies and even hospitals.

    As part of these activities, travellers have become commodities and are traded as valuable assets. The fraudsters have preferred insurance brands that are known to pay invoices quickly and without question, and travellers holding those policies have therefore become valuable assets.

    In a typical scenario, a traveller might complain of a minor ailment while trekking in Nepal’s mountain region. The trekking guide would then send a message to a helicopter charter company, and a commission would be agreed upon (based on their perceived value of the particular insurer covering the traveller). In turn, the helicopter charter company would message hospitals to negotiate a commission, with the highest bidder ‘winning’ the traveller. Insurers are then presented with inflated helicopter invoices and medical bills, and often left with no recourse, as the rescue and so-called treatment had already taken place.

    Trawling the evidence

    During the investigation, Traveller Assist was granted access to 1,000 invoices from prior claims that had happened over a two-year period in Nepal. We were able to cross-reference these claims with over 300 of our own cases from 2017-18, and this allowed us to build a comprehensive intelligence picture that revealed, over and over, the same trekking operators, heli-charter companies and hospitals.

    These companies became the main focus of the investigation, and ultimately led to three sting operations in the country where crucial evidence against these operators was recorded and documented, and a 200-page report was handed over to the Ministry of Law and Justice in Nepal, and the Ministry of Culture, Tourism and Civil Aviation.

    As this was happening, we simultaneously brokered an agreement between three insurance underwriters to give leverage with the Government of Nepal. The reason for this was that the Ministries refused to investigate the fraud claims, despite being presented with evidence of corruption. This resulted in a very public ultimatum to the Government that was broadcast on major news channels, and published in over 30 newspapers and magazines around the world, in 13 languages. The ultimatum was that if action was not taken, insurers would stop issuing policies for travellers visiting Nepal, which would likely result in millions of dollars in loss for the Nepalese government.

    Within 11 days of almost daily media interviews, a Ministry representative informed us that a taskforce was being formed to investigate the reports of fraud, and the Ministry requested that we do not comment to the media further until their investigation was complete. We complied, and within 30 days the Ministry had announced charges against every company in the report that we had presented to them. In addition, five other companies that the task force had found to be complicit in fraud against insurers were charged.

    Trekking operators

    There are over 3,000 licensed trekking companies registered in Nepal, and for many travellers, the trekking guide is the first point of contact in the event of sickness or injury. During the investigation, it was found that some trekking guides were making up to US$30,000 in commissions paid to them by heli-charter companies. It was also found that some trekking companies were purposely making their travellers sick by feeding them unrefrigerated chicken or adding baking soda to food, causing diarrhoea and vomiting.

    Some trekking guides have also been known to make a call to an insurer, or send an email, to inform them of the ill or injured traveller, so that they can prove they informed the insurer, but then they will switch off their phone and blame poor signal connection so the insurer cannot call them back; all the while having another phone that they use to communicate with the helicopter company. In two documented cases, guides were found to have a signal jammer that would stop the travellers from using their phones and contacting their insurers. By the time the insurer has received the case notification, the traveller is often already in the air, on the way to a hospital.

    Guides have also been known to hold travellers for longer, until a helicopter is available from a commission-paying company. This has resulted in sick and injured travellers being forced to stay overnight on the mountain, and in one case, resulted in the death of a traveller who was not provided with timely treatment.

    From the investigation, it was also found that some trekking companies who charged less than $1,000 for a five-day trek were often the ones involved in fraudulent cases – they could afford to charge less for the trek because they knew they would make up the difference from the pending medical ‘rescues’. Unsuspecting travellers would set off on the trek of a lifetime, not knowing that they will never actually make it to their destination.

    It was also these companies who would willingly take travellers to higher altitudes within 24 hours of arriving in the country, not allowing the travellers to acclimatise to the altitude, often resulting in symptoms of acute mountain sickness (AMS). It’s advised that travellers should acclimatise for at least five days upon arrival in Kathmandu, before embarking on an altitude trek. Symptoms of AMS usually develop between six and 24 hours after reaching altitudes of more than 3,000 metres (9,842 feet) above sea level. These symptoms can disappear by descending to a lower altitude of at least 500 metres (1,600 feet). An experienced and reputable trekking operator will descend with a traveller at the first signs of AMS. The fraudulent operators will either keep pushing the traveller, or immediately call for a helicopter.

    Helicopter companies

    It’s important to note that while there are over 20 helicopter companies registered in Nepal, only 10 actually own helicopters. The rest are heli-charter companies. This is the key to fully understanding the extent of the fraud that happens, and how it happens. For us to better understand it, we focused on the owners of each company, which led us to the promoters.

    In every single case of fraud that we found, we narrowed it down to five helicopter charter companies. These companies act as umbrella organisations (promotors), and represent hundreds of trekking companies, and are typically aligned with one helicopter company and one hospital. This facilitates the flow of commissions between the organisations.

    While there are five charter companies, two of them represent the same helicopter company and same hospital, and another two promote a different helicopter company and a different hospital. The fifth one is smaller, and represents less than 100 trekking operators, and promotes a smaller helicopter company and smaller hospital.

    What we then found is that owners, or investors, of these three hospitals also own shares in, or have invested in, the same helicopter companies, same hospitals, and have also invested collectively in over 2,000 trekking companies. When all of the layers are peeled away, a majority of the money defrauded from insurers is being funnelled to a handful of business people, and in one case, a medical doctor.

    Other questionable practices by heli-charter companies have included multiple travellers being loaded onto a helicopter, and then multiple claims being made for that one helicopter. In one particular case, seven claims of over $5,000 were made for one heli rescue, totalling almost $40,000, for a flight that should have cost less than $4,000.

    Hospitals

    Dishonest schemes involving travellers in Nepal don’t always involve a helicopter, but they almost always involve a hospital and, from the results of our investigation, it’s typically one of three hospitals who pay these commissions. In some cases up to $1,000, and not always to helicopter companies. Taxi drivers, hotel operators, and bar owners have also reported being paid commissions by hospitals to direct travellers to their facilities.

    A common tactic used by at least two hospitals is to exaggerate medical symptoms, in some cases even convincing the traveller that they are sicker than they are. The difficulty with AMS is that when a traveller descends to a safer altitude, they start to recover very quickly, which makes it very difficult to prove that a related heli-rescue was unnecessary or that treatment was excessive.

    Hospitals have also been known to hold travellers’ passports until the bill has been paid in full, causing the traveller to panic, and at times blame the insurer. We have also seen the traveller being held in the hospital for three days until their daily card payment limits are reached to pay the outstanding medical bill.

    During our investigation, information also came to light that doctors at one private hospital were conducting surgical procedures on travellers that they are not qualified for, and this has resulted in at least two deaths, including one very recently that is currently under investigation by the Criminal Investigation Division of the Nepal Police.

    Travellers

    Some travellers have also been involved themselves in dubious practices in Nepal, being offered up to $750 to take a helicopter from the mountain back to Kathmandu, and then promised that after one night in a hospital, they will be transferred to a luxury hotel for a couple of nights until their flight home. For some travellers who have spent their savings travelling to Nepal and trekking to Everest base camp, the offer of being paid to take a helicopter back is far too tempting an offer.

    Travellers are also being asked to lie and exaggerate their symptoms when speaking to their insurer. In some cases, being told exactly what to say by the trekking guide, and even by the hospital. The traveller becomes scared that their insurance won’t cover the costs and so, in some cases, they say exactly what they are told to.

    Conclusion

    Statistics released by the department of tourism in Nepal estimate that 20-per-cent more travellers arrived in the country this season (September to November) than last season, yet there have been 60-per-cent fewer helicopter rescues in the country during that time. At the time of writing, heli-rescue flights logged with the tower in Lukla are at just over 1,400, with 70 per cent of those being from one helicopter company. That same helicopter company is promoted by two of the largest heli-charter companies in Nepal, both of which have been charged with fraud, yet they are still operating.

    While unnecessary heli-rescues have fallen significantly, this is not to say that fraud has stopped in the country. This season, our company has provided medical assistance for 123 cases in Nepal, 94 of which involved a helicopter; and in only six of those cases, we received extremely inflated invoices that we were able to negotiate down to reasonable amounts.

    From 14 January 2019, Traveller Assist in partnership with the Ministry of Tourism will staff a kiosk at Kathmandu Airport to educate arriving travellers on how to avoid sickness and injury typical in those visiting the country, and what to do in case of emergency. Additionally, travellers will be able to rent local mobile phones and a text-enabled GPS that has an SOS button monitored by Traveller Assist’s local team. The aim of this proactive approach is to make Nepal safer for travellers and reduce insurance fraud.

    The bottom line for insurers and assistance providers is to understand that by continuing to use ground agents, charter companies and hospitals in Nepal that have already been charged and named by the Government for fraud, and by accepting and paying over-inflated invoices, this is perpetuating the problem, making fraud more difficult to tackle for everyone.  – itij.com

    Danny Kaine is the Head of Assistance for Traveller Assist, a medical assistance and cost containment company specialising in Latin America, Nepal and parts of Africa. He is an ex-soldier and adventurer, with 20 years of experience in complex regions.

    Courtesy : International Travel and Health Insurance Journal ( ITIJ)

    Image : ITIJ / 2019

    • Connecting you with the world of travel and tourism

      28th East Mediterranean Tourism and Travel Exhibition https://emittistanbul.com/en

      Asia Pool & Spa Expo , May 10 – 12, 2025 , Guangzhou , China

      An Opportunity to enter South-East Asian market in 2023

      KAZAKHSTAN International Exhibition “Tourism & Travel” Almaty, Kazakhstan

      CHINA- Beyond your imagination

      Africa and Americas Unite

      at Landmark Summit to Plan

      Shared Tourism Future

      Tourism leaders from both Africa and the Americas have jointly committed to working together to make the sector a pillar of collective sustainable and inclusive development across both continents.

      The “Punta Cana Declaration” was adopted at the conclusion of the very first joint meeting of UN Tourism’s Regional Commissions for Africa and the Americas and followed two days of shared dialogue around the key themes of education and investments into the sector. Recognizing the historic ties between the two regions, as well their unique and complementary cultures, the Summit served as a landmark platform for strengthened cooperation, capitalizing on innovation, education, investments and creative industries for the future development of tourism.

      This summit offers a unique platform to forge connections and build bridges between Africa and the Americas, create strategic cross-regional partnerships, foster South-South cooperation projects, all for the benefit of the tourism sector of the two regions

      Welcoming around 200 high-level participants among them 14 Ministers, representing 27 countries (15 from the Americas and 12 from Africa), UN Tourism Secretary-General Zurab Pololikashvili said: “This summit offers a unique platform to forge connections and build bridges between Africa and the Americas, create strategic cross-regional partnerships, foster South-South cooperation projects, all for the benefit of the tourism sector of the two regions.”  – 3 Oct 2024 ( UN Tourism )

      UNWTO becomes “UN Tourism” 

      The World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) enters a new era  with a new name and brand: UN Tourism. With this new brand, the Organization reaffirms its status as the United Nations specialized agency for tourism and the global leader of tourism for development, driving social and economic change to ensure that “people and planet” are always center stage.

      UN Tourism: Transforming tourism for a better worldTo achieve this goal, UN Tourism engaged the services of Interbrand, the leading global branding agency. Interbrand successfully translated the Organization’s renewed vision for tourism into a new visual identity and brand narrative.

      This involved renaming the Organization, transitioning from UNWTO to UN Tourism. At the same time, a new brand narrative was meticulously crafted, one that seamlessly aligns with UN Tourism’s central mission and priorities. This narrative pivots around three main messages: the UN as a global altruistic organization, the notion of connecting humans around the world, and the concept of proactivity and movement.

      Enhancing the well-being of individuals, safeguarding the natural environment, stimulating economic advancement, and fostering international harmony are key goals that are the fundamental essence of UN Tourism

      By moving away from acronyms, UN Tourism adopts a more approachable stance and capitalizes on its strengths: the “UN”, signifying authority, and tourism, a simple and relatable concept for all. This change has been endorsed by the Organization’s membership, highlighting its united support for the profound transformation and reinvention of UN Tourism in recent years, as it has become more agile, visible, and ever closer to its Member States, partners and the sector as a whole.

      With 160 Member States and hundreds of private sector affiliates, UN Tourism has its headquarters in Madrid, Spain, and Regional Offices in Nara (Japan) covering Asia & Pacific, Riyadh (Saudi Arabia) for the Middle East, as well as forthcoming Regional Offices for the Americas (Rio de Janeiro, Brazil) and Africa (Morocco). Its priorities center on promoting tourism for sustainable development in line with the UN’s 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and its 17 Global Goals. UN Tourism promotes quality education, supports decent jobs in the sector, identifies talent and drives innovation and accelerates tourism climate action and sustainability . – UN Tourism Jan. 2024

      TAT launches

      “Thais Always Care” Campaign 

      “The Tourism Authority of Thailand launches ‘Thais Always Care’ campaign in collaboration with other organizations to ensure tourists’ safety and enhance positive image.”

      The “Thais Always Care” online communication campaign was officially launched by the Tourism Authority of Thailand (TAT) in collaboration with the Tourist Police Bureau, Grab Taxi (Thailand), and Central Pattana (CPN) to ensure the safety and welcome of tourists from around the world. The campaign aims to provide seamless travel experiences for visitors to Thailand while also reinforcing the positive image of the country as a safe destination.

      The campaign reflects Thailand’s renowned hospitality and warmth to visitors, showcasing the country as a desirable destination for tourists. “CARE” stands for Compassion, Assistant, Relief, and Elevate, encompassing the generosity of the Thai people and their commitment to providing a safe and enjoyable travel experience for tourists.

      Partners involved in the campaign have strengthened their safety measures and are utilizing technology to ensure the safety of tourists in Thailand. This includes installing CCTV cameras, implementing strict security checks at department stores, and utilizing technology like the “POLICE I LERT U” application to offer emergency assistance to international visitors. The campaign will also involve working with international KOLs to enhance the positive image of Thailand’s tourism assets and reinforce the country’s reputation as a safe destination. -Tourism Authority of Thailand

      China’s resort island receives

      90 m tourists in 2023

      More than 90 million domestic and overseas tourists visited south China’s tropical island province of Hainan in 2023, up 49.9 percent year on year, local authorities said .

      Hainan’s total tourism revenue surged 71.9 percent year on year to about 181.3 billion yuan (about 25.5 billion U.S. dollars) in 2023, according to the provincial department of tourism, culture, radio, television and sports.

      Last year, Hainan experienced rapid development in cruise tourism. Cruises to the Xisha Islands in the South China Sea saw 400 trips, up 277.8 percent year on year, and received 149,400 domestic tourists, up 405.33 percent.

      This year, Hainan aims to receive 99 million tourists and its tourism revenue is expected to reach 207 billion yuan. The province aims to receive more than 1 million inbound tourists in 2024.

      China aims to build Hainan into an international tourism and consumption center by 2025 and a globally influential tourism and consumption destination by 2035. – Xinhua

      Vietnam  to welcome 17-18

      million tourists  this year

      Việt Nam’s tourism industry has set a target to welcome 17-18 million foreign visitors in 2024, approaching the pre-pandemic record in 2019 when COVID-19 had yet to disrupt global travel.

      In 2023, the figure hit 12.6 million, surpassing the initial target set earlier in the year (before China, which accounted for a third of foreign arrivals to Việt Nam pre-pandemic, announced reopening plans) by 57 per cent and achieving the adjusted goal of 12-13 million.

      The number of domestic travellers, meanwhile, stood at 108 million, up 6 per cent compared to the set target. Tourism activities generated about VNĐ678 trillion (US$27.85 billion) in revenue, 4.3 per cent higher than the yearly plan.

      Despite substantial recovery in 2023, the Việt Nam National Authority of Tourism (VNAT) said the domestic tourism recovery will still face challenges in the year ahead. This is particularly true in the context of the unpredictable global developments stemming from economic uncertainties, regional conflicts and climate change.

      Việt Nam’s socio-economic conditions remain stable; the economy continues to grow and inflation has been kept in check. But the persistent threat of disease and natural disasters are likely to create uncertainty affecting production, business activities and the daily lives of citizens.

      According to forecasts from the UN World Tourism Organisation and the World Travel and Tourism Council, international travel activities may fully recover by the end of 2024, reaching the levels achieved in 2019. However, the recovery is expected to be uneven across different regions.

      The ever-changing demands of international tourists require higher standards in product quality, diversity and unique experiences. The trends of integrating information technology, artificial intelligence and digital transformation are envisioned to drive the emergence of new forms of tourism.

      Based on these analyses and projections, Việt Nam aims to serve 17-18 million foreign and 110 million domestic visitors this year, with an expected total revenue from tourism nearing VNĐ840 trillion.

      To achieve the stated objectives, Minister of Culture, Sports and Tourism Nguyễn Văn Hùng has instructed the VNAT to continue focusing on advising and improving the institutional framework, policies, reviewing identified deficiencies for adjustment, and international commitments in the field of tourism. Collaboration with other ministries and sectors is emphasised to formulate policies for developing various types of products such as agricultural tourism and digital transformation in tourism. He also noted the need for attention on strengthening tourism statistics and digital transformation to enhance the effectiveness of data collection, providing reliable figures to efficiently support tourism policy planning.

      The ministry also calls for enhanced training for tourism officials and workers to meet requirements of new situations, especially in terms of language proficiency and technology expertise. — VNS

      Global Medical Tourism market 

      USD 136.93 billion in 10 years

      Newark, Jan. 01, 2024 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — The Brainy Insights estimates that the USD 20.07 billion in 2022 global Medical Tourism market will reach USD 136.93 billion by 2032. There is a growing trend towards health and wellness tourism, with individuals seeking medical treatments, preventive care, wellness programs, and holistic health experiences. Medical tourism destinations can capitalize on this trend by offering comprehensive health and wellness packages.

      Furthermore, integrating digital health technologies, including telemedicine, virtual consultations, and electronic health records, can enhance the accessibility and coordination of medical tourism services. Digital platforms can streamline pre-travel consultations, post-treatment follow-ups, and information exchange between healthcare providers and patients. Introducing new and advanced medical treatments, therapies, and procedures can attract medical tourists seeking cutting-edge healthcare solutions. Countries and healthcare providers that stay at the forefront of medical innovation can position themselves as leaders in the industry.

      In addition, customized and personalized medical tourism packages catering to individual patient’s unique needs and preferences present an opportunity for service providers. Tailoring experiences that include cultural activities, recovery retreats, and concierge services can set providers apart in a competitive market.

      Besides, wellness tourism, including genetic testing and personalized health assessments, is gaining traction. Medical tourism destinations can offer specialized wellness packages, including genetic evaluations and preventive health screenings, to attract individuals interested in proactive healthcare.

      FACTS —

      Tourism helps in:

      👉Reducing poverty

      👉Reducing Inequalities

      👉Promoting gender equality

      👉Fostering decent work and economic growth

      World Tourism Day 2021: ‘Tourism for Inclusive Growth’

      In 2019, Travel & Tourism’s direct, indirect and induced impact accounted for:
      -US$8.9 trillion contribution to the world’s GDP
      -10.3% of global GDP
      -330 million jobs, 1 in 10 jobs around the world
      -US$1.7 trillion visitor exports (6.8% of total exports,
      28.3% of global services exports)
      -US$948 billion capital investment (4.3% of total
      investment)